Starters | Soups | Salads | Sides | Sandwiches | Pasta | Entrees | Desserts | Specialty Drinks
Fried alligator tail seasoned and lightly breaded. Traditional or buffalo style.
Shucked per order. Raw or steamed.
Lightly breaded, deep fried and served with marinara sauce.
A half pound of shrimp served with cocktail sauce.
Jalapenos stuffed with cream cheese. Served with fruit salsa for dipping.
A healthy flavorful spread served with a variety of veggies, crackers, and jalapenos.
Clams lightly breaded and deep fried.
A mildly spicy blend of conch, peppers, and onions. Served with Key West Remoulade sauce.
A heap of french fries smothered with our new “Gator Chili” and topped with melted mixed cheese.
A hearty helping of lightly breaded deep fried shrimp. Traditional or buffalo style.
Lightly breaded and deep fried. Served with Honey Mustard sauce.
Our flakey delicious white fish cut into bite sized pieces. Lightly breaded and deep fried.
A healthy portion of Kermit’s finest. Lightly breaded and fried. Try them with buffalo sauce on the side.
Be ready to order another drink. Enjoy Gator Joe’s unique appetizer.
Oysters lightly breaded and deep fried to a golden brown.
Tasty mozzarella cheese sticks fried golden brown.
A generous portion of onion rings, deep fried to a golden brown.
Tasty chicken wings lightly breaded and deep fried. Pick Your Flavor: Mild, Medium, Hot, or Garlic.10 Piece....20 Piece....50 Piece....
back to top
Creamy white clam chowder made Gator Joe’s way! Served in a bread bowl topped with parsley.
A tasty combination of Cajun spices blended with sausage, chicken and ham, served over Joe’s kickin’ rice and a hot piece of cornbread.
Our newest creation from Joe! Chili like you’ve never had it before... Only at Gator Joe’s!
Dressings: Bleu Cheese, Ranch, Honey Mustard, Italian, Oil & Vinegar
Mixed greens with lettuce, tomato, and onion.
A blend of fresh shrimp and krabmeat on a bed of mixed greens and vegetables. Served with our Key West Remoulade dressing! $9.99 J. Edgar’s Caesar Salad Mr. Hoover loved this one. Rumor has it he ate one just before the Barker shootout!Add chicken, shrimp, or gator for an additional charge
Black Eyed Peas
All sandwiches are served with chips, lettuce, tomato & onion, and a pickle spear.*Onion rings may be substituted for an additional charge
Oyster, Gator, Shrimp, Fish, or Clams A Lake Weir style sandwich with your choice of seafood.
Grilled seasoned steak smothered with mushrooms and onions then topped with melted provolone or American cheese. If chicken is your favorite, just say "Chicken Philly".
Get this tasty fish sandwich grilled, blackened, or fried.
A tender chicken breast that comes grilled, blackened or fried. Available with Honey Mustard sauce or BBQ glaze.
Try our tender chicken breast, fried or grilled, then topped with Mama’s red sauce and parmesan cheese.
Our seasoned gator tail smothered with mushrooms and onions, topped with melted provolone or American cheese.
Our awesome Alaskan Pollock, lightly breaded and deep fried. Served with tartar sauce.
Our "Catch of the Day" may be grilled, blackened or fried. Served with tartar sauce.
A half pound of choice sirloin grilled medium, medium well, or well.
ITALIAN MEATBALL SUB Try our tasty Italian meatballs on a hoagie roll topped with Mama’s red sauce and melted provolone cheese.
All pastas served with toasted garlic bread.
A wonderful blend of shrimp, imitation crabmeat and pasta sautéed in our Gator Joe’s lobster bisque.
Fresh shrimp sautéed in white wine, lemon, butter and pasta. Topped with parmesan cheese. *Chicken available if you prefer.
No one does it like Mama! Our pasta is served with a zesty blend of fresh mushrooms, onions, peppers and garlic.
A zesty blend of sautéed mushrooms, onions, peppers, cucumbers and celery topped with fresh tomatoes and parmesan cheese.Add chicken, shrimp, or Italian meatballs for an additional charge
Dinners include Joe’s Kickin’ Rice & Black-Eyed Peas. Baskets include fries & coleslaw.Add a House Salad for an additional charge
Florida Grill Dinner Ask your server about today’s catch. If you missed the sign.
A 10-12 oz. steak lover’s steak. Hand cut and seasoned by Gator Joe himself and grilled to your special temperature.
Two chicken breasts, grilled or fried, served over a bed of pasta and topped with Joe’s Mama’s red sauce and Parmesan. Served with garlic bread.
Joe says "By far, the best on the lake!"
Two grilled chicken breasts served plain, blackened, or glazed with Honey Mustard or BBQ sauce.
Fresh and tender Mahi Mahi cooked your way. Grilled, blackened or fried. Served with a fruit salsa.
Our #1 seller! Tender Alaskan Pollock lightly breaded and deep fried golden brown.
Delicious lightly breaded and deep fried shrimp. Awesome! Ask Joe yourself!
Freshly marinated gator tail, lightly breaded and fried.
Lightly breaded clams fried to a golden brown.
A healthier portion of Kermit’s finest lightly breaded and deep fried. Try them with buffalo sauce on the side.
CREATE YOUR OWN FRIED SEAFOOD DINNER!
SHRIMP • FISH • FROG LEGS GATOR • CLAMS • OYSTERS
Served all day with fries and slaw.
FRIED SHRIMP
FRIED FISH
Top off your meal Key West style with Gator Joe’s cool Key Lime pie topped with a slice of lime.
Cookies and Cream ice cream layered with creamy vanilla & chocolate fudge and topped with crushed chocolate cookies.
Your favorite Oreo cookies swirled into creamy cheesecake!
Caramel ice cream blended with praline caramel fudge and layered with caramel flavored mousse and crunchy glazed pecans.
Malibu Rum, Midori, and Pineapple Juice topped off with a Myers Rum float!
Mango Daiquiri, Malibu Rum
Raspberry & Pina Colada Daiquiri sittin’ pretty with a Myer’s Rum floater
Razzmatazz, Malibu Rum, Pineapple Juice
Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Lemonade Root Beer, Iced Tea, Dasani Water